When Andreas Flaten left his job at a Georgia auto repair shop, he was still waiting for his final paycheck.
The amount he said he was owed wasn’t enormous:
$915.
Eventually, he got his money.
But it didn’t arrive as a check or direct deposit.
Instead, tens of thousands of pennies were dumped at his home.
Approximately 91,500 of them.
And according to Flaten, the coins were covered in an oily substance.
What initially sounded like a bizarre dispute between a worker and his former boss eventually became much more serious.
The U.S. Department of Labor became involved, filed a federal complaint and accused the employer of retaliation and other violations.
Years later, the case resulted in a federal judgment requiring nearly $40,000 in back wages and damages for multiple employees.
It Started With a Missing $915 Paycheck
Flaten had worked as a manager at A OK Walker Autoworks in Peachtree City, Georgia.
After leaving the business following a dispute, he said he was still owed $915 in final wages.
When the payment didn’t arrive, Flaten contacted the U.S. Department of Labor.
Then something extraordinary appeared outside his home.
A massive pile of pennies.
There were roughly 91,500 coins—enough to equal approximately $915.
The pennies weighed around 500 pounds.
But the quantity wasn’t the only problem.
They were coated in an oily substance.
The Pennies Were Dumped at His Home
News reports at the time showed the enormous pile sitting outside Flaten’s home.
A pay stub was reportedly left with the coins along with an insulting message.
Flaten said the pennies were so greasy that simply dealing with them became a major project.
Cleaning and moving approximately 500 pounds of coins isn’t comparable to depositing an ordinary paycheck.
He told reporters that cleaning only a small amount had already taken considerable time.
The story quickly attracted national attention.
People debated whether paying someone in pennies was technically legal.
But the more important legal issue would eventually become something else.
The Labor Department Called It Retaliation
In January 2022, the U.S. Department of Labor announced that it had filed a complaint in federal court against the auto repair shop and its owner, Miles Walker.
The department alleged that the penny payment was retaliatory.
According to the Labor Department, Flaten had contacted its Wage and Hour Division after resigning and not receiving his final wages.
The complaint alleged that Walker responded by delivering approximately 91,500 oil-covered pennies to Flaten’s home.
The department also alleged that the employer published defamatory statements about the former worker on the company’s website.
At that point, the story was no longer simply about an unusual final paycheck.
It had become a federal labor case.
‘He Got Paid’
When reporters initially questioned Walker about the pennies, his response attracted further attention.
His position, broadly, was that Flaten had received the money he was owed.
But federal labor officials saw the situation differently.
The Department of Labor argued that workers have the right to contact the agency about wages without being retaliated against for doing so.
That distinction became central to the case.
Paying the $915 didn’t automatically settle the question of how and why it had been paid that way.
The Case Expanded Beyond the Pennies
The government’s investigation didn’t stop with Flaten’s unusual payment.
Labor officials also identified alleged overtime and recordkeeping violations affecting other employees.
The Department of Labor sought back wages and damages.
By 2023, the federal case had reached a significant resolution.
A federal judge ordered the auto repair business and its owner to pay employees nearly $40,000 in back wages and liquidated damages.